Read About My Two Volume Encyclopedia

Home Page What's New: Multinational Corporate Crime Crimes of the Powerful & State-Routinized Crime Social Justice Theft of a Nation Slide Show Addressing Wall Street Securities Fraud in the 21st Century WikiLeaks--Will the Public Remember? Mass Media & Crime Review Essay on Race Crime and Justice Terrorism Economic Crisis & State-Corporate Crime Crimes of State CSI or Tech Effect? Supranational  Criminology Peacemaking  Criminology Theories  of Violence Newsmaking  Criminology Mediatizing Law and Order Speaking of Class Race and Gender Integrative  Criminology Global  Criminology Transnational  Crime Visionary  Criminology Read About My Books Read About My Anthologies Read About My Two Volume Encyclopedia Book Review of Criminology An Integrated Approach Sexual Serial Killer Jack Unterweger Contact Me Blog

CONTROVERSIES IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE

BATTLEGROUND: CRIMINAL JUSTICE

 

Gregg Barak

Editor

 

Greenwood Press, 2007


Preface

Content


Battleground: Criminal Justice is a comprehensive two-volume set that discusses the major controversies or issues involving the administration of criminal justice. The 100 entries of this reference work, written by approximately 100 expert contributors span the criminal justice system of the United States, with a few entries included that deal with instructive foreign criminal justice issues, such as prison problems in the Caribbean and post-apartheid justice in South Africa. They also include entries on some of the crimes or criminals caught up in these controversies of crime control, such as those involving domestic violence and sexual assault or acts by sexual offenders or perpetrators who have been diagnosed as legally insane. In addition, these entries address controversies of criminal justice, as they cut across a full array of institutional arrangements, including social, political, economic, and legal. These entries move beyond criminal justice and are inclusive of all sectors of society.

Perhaps, what is most significant about these “controversies in criminal justice” are the cultural imprints that these entries represent. That is say, the controversies hoisted and elucidated upon here reflect a multiplicity of cultural stances, including “liberal,” “moderate,” “radical,” and “conservative” points of view. The important relevant arguments pertaining to any of these controversies will be found within this two-volume encyclopedia. The leading principle in presenting the information on these controversies is, wherever possible, to locate and to be guided by the empirical (research) realities underlying these debates, controversies, or disagreements.

Arrangement

The issues of criminal justice profiled here are arranged alphabetically. Following the table of contents is a list of all the entries in alphabetical order. As a further guide to the reader, however, a topically arranged list of all the entries, “The Guide to Related Entries,” which follows the alphabetical list. Here you will discover if you have not already done so that I have classified the 100 entries into six areas or clusters: Law and Society; Law Enforcement; Prosecution, Courts, and Adjudication; Punishment and Corrections; Science and Criminal Justice; and Society, Crime, and Justice. Although I have classified them into the six clusters, some of these could have been ordered under another heading. For example, “The Exclusionary Rule,” The Second Amendment,” or “Expert Witness Testimony” could each be catalogued under Prosecution, Courts, and Adjudication.. The comprehensive index at the end of the second volume will give the reader more options for subject access to the contents of this work.

Entries

Each entry runs from approximately 2,000 to 2500 words. Although there are some deviations specific to most of the entries, all entries present a sequence of the following sections:

  • Introduction, where the controversy is briefly summarized.
  • Background, where the controversy is presented historically.
  • Key Events, where important dealings, ideas, or persons are reviewed.
  • Future Prospects, where the controversies are speculated as to what they might look like.
  • Recommend Reading, with usually 5 to 7 suggested books or articles or an occasional website.
  • Endnotes, where particular citations quoted from or used appear.

The encyclopedia closes with a bibliography of useful materials on general topics in criminal justice and a subject index.

Criminal Justice Issues in This Work

There are at least four trends or common denominators that apply to most of the entries in this encyclopedia. First, although fresh controversies emerge from time to time, especially propelled by new technologies such as the use of DNA testing to convict or extricate an alleged offender of a crime, or by the introduction of pioneering laws such as those prohibiting “stalking” or the expanded “pollution” of the environment, most controversies in criminal justice or between the rights of the individual versus the rights of the state have a relatively long history, some dating as far back as the signing of the Magna Carta in 1215. In that historic moment, in a small borough outside of London called Runnymede, King John acquiesced to his barons and agreed to document the protected rights of feudal lords, setting the stage for what would eventually evolve into legal procedures —the “rule of law”—that both subjects and kings alike would have to abide by or suffer the legal consequences.

Second, although the policies and practices surrounding some of the newer controversies in criminal justice have not been reviewed or tested by appellate courts, let alone the U.S. Supreme Court, most of these have an established legal history as well, lone that is legislative, if not also judicial. For example, the legal definitions of the insanity defense have been changing for more than 150 years. More generally, what is considered as “criminal” or as “criminal violence” has been evolving at least since the 13th century and continues right up to this day. Similarly, the consequences or punishments for violating the criminal law have also varied considerably. For example, not all states in the U.S. have the death penalty and for a brief three year period, 1973 to 1976, the Supreme Court outlawed the death penalty across the nation.

Third, although many of the controversies examined here are complex, most come to be viewed dualistically or in terms of one side versus another side. In terms of the public’s attitudes toward the death penalty or the Patriot Act, for example, or regarding the views of the efficacy of these practices by professional justicians, sides are usually reduced to those who are either “pro” or “con,” “in favor of” or “opposed to.” On closer scrutiny, however, there are usually more sides to these controversies than these simple dichotomies. While some folks may be opposed to or in favor of the death penalty, there are others who find the death penalty acceptable under certain conditions and unacceptable under other conditions. Similarly, when it comes to the controversial Patriot Act, Homeland Security Act, or the Military Commissions Act (related to “unlawful enemy combatant,” such as those held at Guantanamo Air Base, there are also persons who are in favor of some provisions and opposed to other provisions.

Fourth, from time to time a few of these controversies seem to have been put to sleep, such as the right of all persons accused of a felony crime to be represented by an attorney at law, whether they can afford one or not, as was the case in 1963 with Gideon v. Wainwright, but most of the controversies in criminal justice will continue to be debated well into the future like treatment versus punishment, gun control, or the police use of racial profiling. And “settled issues” often spawn or evolve into related issues of controversy. In the case of post-Gideon matters of legal representation, for example, one issue today has to do with whether or not and when is it acceptable for an indigent criminal defendant to waive his or her right to appointed counsel? Finally, even when the law eliminates or abolishes certain policies or practices such as the United States did with indeterminate sentencing in the 1970s or federal parole in the 1980s, controversies may persist around the value of resurrecting these. In the 1970s, for example, the death penalty was declared to be unconstitutional by the Supreme Court and executions were stopped for a short period of time, until it subsequently reversed itself a few years later.

Thus, even when practices and policies seem fixed or permanent in stature, without controversies surrounding them, they may, in fact, be subject to change. For example, the original human right (the “Great Writ”) of habeas corpus giving every citizen the right to challenge the legality of his or her detention by the state, first codified by the British Parliament in 1640 and 1679 and one of a handful of common laws explicitly referred to and protected in the U.S. Constitution, seemed to be invincible or beyond reproach. In 2006, however, the Great Writ was substantially weakened by the passage of the Military Commissions Act. This act passed by the Congress and signed by President George W. Bush eliminated habeas corpus for anyone defined as an “unlawful enemy combatant,” as well as all aliens, including permanent residents—green card holders—in the United States. It appears that federal courts, at least for the time being, have been stripped of their historical role in assessing the legality of detentions, so long as the executive branch claims that these arrests are part of the “war on terror.” Of course, it will not be too long before a test case of the Military Commissions Act finds itself winding up to the U.S. Supreme Court for review of its constitutionality.

In sum, when it comes to “law and order” or to “equal [criminal] justice for all,” virtually no policies or practices are absolute or constant; all are subject to reform, change, repudiation, or innovation. From time to time these policies, controversial or not, will be subjected to new laws and new interpretations of those rules, reflecting a much older social and cultural controversy about where we as a civil society draw the lines between the rights of the individual to his liberty or freedom “versus” the rights of the state to maintain the peace, property, and security of all. Hence, as you read these different thought-provoking entries on and beyond criminal justice, keep in mind that most of these controversies will have a past, a present, and a future.

Gregg Barak, Eastern Michigan University

General Editor

 


Law and Society (18)

  • Anti-Terrorist Laws
  • Controlling State Crime
  • Enforcement of Immigration & Employment Laws
  • Enforcing International Humanitarian Law
  • Espionage Act of 1917
  • Exclusionary Rule
  • Felony Disenfranchisement Laws
  • Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act
  • Gang Injunction Laws
  • Homeland Security Act
  • Patriot Act
  • Search Warrants
  • Second Amendment
  • Sex Offender Law
  • Stalking Laws
  • Supremacy of International Law to National Law
  • Three Strike Laws
  • Torture and Enemy Combatants

Law Enforcement (10)

  • Community Policing
  • Driving While Black
  • Lethal Force
  • Militarization of Policing
  • Miranda Warnings
  • Police Brutality
  • Police Corruption
  • Police Minority Relations
  • Police Use of Force
  • Psychological Screening of Police

Prosecution, Courts, and Adjudication (14)

  • Adversarial Justice
  • Alternative Responses to Crime
  • Bail
  • Cameras in the Courtroom
  • Conspiracy and Substantial Assistance
  • Eye Witness Identification
  • International Criminal Court
  • Problem-Solving Courts
  • Prosecutorial Discretion
  • Representing Indigent Defendants
  • Restorative Justice
  • Sentencing and Judicial Discretion
  • Trial Consultants
  • Tribal Courts

Punishment and Corrections (25)

  • Boot Camps
  • Clemency
  • Convict Criminology
  • Corporal Punishment
  • Correctional Education
  • Cruel and Unusual Punishments
  • Dangerous Offenders
  • Death Penalty
  • Determinate and Indeterminate Sentencing
  • Faith Based Prison Programming
  • Guantanomo
  • Incarcerated Hawaiians
  • New Penology
  • Parole
  • Prison Construction
  • Prison Privatization
  • Prison Rape
  • Prison Sexual Assault
  • Prison Violence in the Caribbean
  • Prisoner Experimentation
  • Prisoner Litigation
  • Spiritual Care of Inmates
  • Supermax Prisons
  • Televised Executions
  • Treating Juveniles as Adults

Science and Criminal Justice (10)

  • COMPSTAT and Crime Reduction
  • CSI Effect
  • DNA
  • DWI and Drug Testing
  • Environmental Crime
  • Expert Witness Testimony
  • Forensic Psychology
  • Marihuana Medicalization (“Legalization”)
  • Mental Health and Insanity
  • Technological Surveillance

Society, Crime, and Justice (24)

  • African American Justice
  • Class Justice
  • College Sexual Assault
  • Consuming Culture and Crime Control
  • Defining Criminal Violence
  • Domestic Violence Practices
  • Equal Justice and Human Rights
  • Gendered Justice
  • Gun Control
  • Juvenile Justice
  • Juveniles and Social Justice
  • Media Portrayal of Criminal Justice
  • Miscarriages of Justice
  • Peacemaking Criminology
  • Post-Apartheid Justice in South Africa
  • Provoking Assaults and High-Profile Crimes
  • Racial Profiling
  • Risk Management
  • School Violence
  • Sex Offender Registries
  • Social Justice
  • South African Criminal Justice
  • The Crime Control Industry
  • War on Drugs

 


 



Contributors and Entry Topics

 

Jeffrey M. London

            Marihuana Medicalization ("Legalization")

Jim Thomas

            Sex-offender Registration (co-auhor Will Mingus)

            Prisoner Litigation

            Faith-based Prison Programming (co-author Joss Stone)

Dawn Rothe

            International Criminal Court (co-author Christopher Mullins)

            1917 Espionage Act

 Lisa Anne Zilney

            War on Drugs

            Sexual Offender Laws (co-author Laura Joan Zilney)

 Donna Killingbeck

            Prison Privatization

 Jeffrey Ross

            Super-maximum Prisons

            Guantanamo

Dominique Robert

            New Penology

Michael Coyle

            Media Portrayals of Criminal Justice

Mathew Yeager

            Classifying Dangerous Offenders

 Lynn Chancer

            Provoking Assaults and High-Profile Crime

Allison Cotton

            Eye Witness Identifications

            Expert Witnesses

 

Diane Williams

            Alternative Responses to Crime

 

Oko Elechi

            Community Policing

            Restorative Justice

Cary Stacy Smith

            Treating Juvenile Offenders as Adults (co-author Li-Ching Hung)

            Boot Camps (co-author Li-Ching Hung)

            U.S. Patriot Act (co-author Li-Ching Hung)

Paul Leighton

            Televised Electrocutions

            Corporal Punishment

 

Venessa Garcia

            Gendered Justice

            Domestic Violence Practices

 

Roslyn Muraskin           

            Criminal Defense Representation (co-author)

Steve Russell

            2nd Amendment

            Criminal Jurisdiction of Tribal Courts

Tawandra L. Rowell

            Prison Sexual Assault

Julia Selman-Ayetey

            DNA Usages in Criminal Justice

Karen Glover

            Police-Minority Relations

            Racial Profiling

Stephen Muzzatti

            Consuming Culture & Crime Control 

Marilyn Corsianos

            Police Corruption

 Everette Penn

            Homeland Security

 Jo-Ann Della Giustina

            Miranda Warnings

 Kate Fox

            Controlling Environmental Crime

            Stalking Laws

            Prison Rape

Ken Mentor

            Corrections Education

            Felony Disenfranchisement Laws

Julien Olivier

            Spiritual Care of the Incarcerated

Al Piscotta

            African-American Criminal (In) Justice


Keith Logan

            Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act

 

Jonathan Kremser

            Search Warrants

 Juan (Xuan) Santos

            Gang Injunction Laws (co-author Rebecca Romo)

 Dave Khey

            Cameras in the Courtroom

 Richelle Swan

            Problem-Solving Courts

 

William Shulman

            Exclusionary Rule

 William Farrell

            Torture and Enemy Combatants

 Catherine Marie Marcum

            Mental Health & Insanity

 Mari Pierce

            Parole

David Strauss

            Militarization of Policing

 Rick Steinmann

            Bail

            Three Strike Laws

Andreas Tomaszewski

             Enforcement of Immigration  & Employment

Jessica Henry

            Police Brutality

 Dawn Worsley Caradonna

            Substantial Assistance & Conspiracy Cases

Gregg Barak

            Class Justice (co-author Paul Leighton)

 Michael S. Bryant

            Enforcing International Humanitarian Law

            Supremacy of International Law over Domestic Law

 Eric Primm

            Juveniles and Social Justice (co-authors Robert M. Regoli and John Hewitt)

Leanne Owen

            School Violence

Aviva Glasner

            Prisoner Experimentation

Stephen C. Richards

            Convict Criminology (co-author Jeffrey Ross)

Robert Bohm

            Miscarriages of Justice

            Death Penalty/Capital Punishment

 Kevin E. McCarthy

            Prosecutorial Discretion

 Angela Taylor

            DWI & Drug Policy

            Lethal Force

Matt Nobles

            Gun Control

 Devyani Prabhat

            Anti-Terrorist Laws

Gregg Barak

            Equal Justice and Human Rights

RaeDeen M.Keahiolalo Karasuda

            Incarcerated Hawaiians

Barbara Hayler

            Determinate and Indeterminate Sentencing

 Douglas Thomas

            Post-Apartheid Justice in South Africa

 Erika Davis-Frenzel

            Sentencing and Judicial Discretion

 Saran Ghatak

            Risk Management

 Randy Shelden

            Crime Control Industry

 Nandi Elizabeth Dill

            Driving While Black

 Byron Price

            Prison Construction

            COMSTAT and Crime Reduction  (co-authors Wenxuan Yu and Lelia Sadeghi)

            Social Justice  (co-authors Lelia Sadeghi and Wenxuan Yu)

Gregg Barak

            Peacemaking Criminology

Patrice Morris

            Prison Violence in the Caribbean

Peter Iadicola

            Defining Violence in Relation to Justice

Livy Visano

            Adversarial Justice 


Kay Scarborough

           Technological Surveillance (co-author Pam Collins) 

Donald Shelton

          CSI Effect

Walter Dekeseredy (co-author William Flack)

          College Sexual Assault

 Stephen Verrill

         Psychological Screening of Police (co-author Aviva Glasner)

         Police Use of Force (co-author Kevin Krug)

         Forensic Psychology (co-author Kevin Krug)

 Christopher Bickel

        Juvenile Justice